Non-Manipulable Things? Maintaining a Techno-Judicial Imaginary on Sealed Biological Samples in the French Criminal Justice
Abstract
This article investigates the maintenance of sealed biological samples in the context of the French criminal justice. It extends maintenance studies to judicial objects and introduces the topic of maintenance in legal materiality studies. Our contribution to these two bodies of literature is to deepen understanding of the epistemic and material politics of maintenance in a judicial context where the issue of authenticity of objects is crucial because of their legal liability. Sealed biological samples, which are associated to a techno-judicial imaginary on cold cases, exacerbate this issue of authenticity. Once sealed, biological samples used to produce forensic DNA profiles are stored for a period of 40 years at the Central Service for the Preservation of Biological Samples – Service Central de Préservation des Prélèvements Biologiques (SCPPB), a dedicated facility, and interventions are no longer authorised on them. What then does it entail to maintain these objects which are non-manipulable, at least to some extent? What are the ‘sciences of maintenance’ mobilised and generated for this purpose, if they exist at all? This article addresses these questions, drawing on the archives of the technical committee of the Fichier National Automatisé des Empreintes Génétiques (FNAEG)—the French national forensic database used by national police—from 1998 to 2016 and on a six-hour interview with the lieutenant-colonel head of the SCPPB. It shows how sealed biological samples raise intertwined debates on their very nature and on the competences and responsibilities of genetic experts, the SCPPB and the judicial authorities on the maintenance of their technical quality and their judicial potential. It examines the knowledges and practices of maintenance of these objects, which are distributed all along the process from their manufacturing on the crime scenes to their preservation at the SCPPB. Finally, it contributes analysis of the temporality of maintenance and the objects to be maintained. By and large, this article offers reflections on the subtle ways of maintenance in the material ordering of the judicial world.
References
Act No. 98-468. 1998. “Loi du 17 juin 1998 relative à la prévention et à la répression des infractions sexuelles ainsi qu'à la protection des mineurs” [Act of June 17, 1998 on the prevention of recidivism and the repression of sexual offenses and the protection of minors], Act No. 98-468, Code de procédure pénale [Code of criminal procedure], Paragraphs 131.10–2270.1. Accessed January 24, 2024.
https://www.legifrance.gouv.fr/jorf/id/JORFTEXT000000556901.
Act No. 1729. 2021. “Loi du 22 décembre 2021 pour la confiance dans l'institution judiciaire” [Act of December 22, 2021 for confidence in the judicial institution]. Act No. 2021-1729. Accessed January 14, 2024.
https://www.legifrance.gouv.fr/dossierlegislatif/JORFDOLE000043370376/.
Agence France Presse (AFP). 2021. “Les scellés du tribunal, entre caverne d’Ali Baba et petite boutique des horreurs criminelles” [The seals of the court, between Ali Baba’s cave and little shop of criminal horrors]. L’Express, April 29, 2021. Accessed January 14, 2024.
Article 97. [1957] 2019. Code de procédure pénale [Code of criminal procedure]. Legislative part, book I, title III, chapter I, section 3, sub-section 1, article No. 97. December 31, 1957. Last Modified March 23, 2019. Accessed January 14, 2024.
https://www.legifrance.gouv.fr/codes/article_lc/LEGIARTI000038312157.
Article 937. [1957] 2020. Code de procédure pénale [Code of criminal procedure]. Legislative part, book I, title II, chapter I, article No. 56. December 31, 1957. Last Modified December 27, 2020. Légifrance (Online). Accessed January 14, 2024.
https://www.legifrance.gouv.fr/codes/article_lc/LEGIARTI000042779588.
Barnes, Jessica. 2017. “States of Maintenance: Power, Politics, and Egypt’s Irrigation Infrastructure.” Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 35(1): 146–164.
https://doi.org/10.1177/0263775816655161.
Callén, Blanca, and Tomás Sánchez Criado. 2015. “Vulnerability Tests: Matters of ‘Care for Matter’ in E-Waste Practices.” Tecnoscienza: Italian Journal of Science & Technology Studies 6(2): 17–40.
https://doi.org/10.6092/issn.2038-3460/17252.
Cohn, Marisa Leavitt. 2013. “Lifetimes and Legacies: Temporalities of Sociotechnical Change in a Long-Lived System.” Ph. D. Dissertation. University of California, Irvine.
https://eric.ed.gov/?id=ED563932.
Combrousse, Philippe. 2017. “Dans le secret des scellés” [In the secret of the seals]. La Presse de Vesoul, February 15, 2017. Accessed January 14, 2024.
https://www.lapressedevesoul.com/actualite-26491-dans-le-secret-des-scelles.html.
Crispino, Frank. 2006. “Le principe de Locard est-il scientifique? Ou analyse de la scientificité des principes fondamentaux de la criminalistique” [Is the Locard principle scientific? Or an analysis of the scientificity of the fundamental principles of forensic science]. Ph.D. Dissertation, Ecole des Sciences Criminelles, Institute of Police Scientifique, Université de Lausanne. Accessed January 14, 2024.
https://www.unil.ch/esc/files/live/sites/esc/files/shared/These_Crispino1.pdf.
Decree No. 2000-413. [2000] 2001. Last Modified July 13, 2001. Accessed January 24, 2024.
https://www.legifrance.gouv.fr/loda/id/JORFTEXT000000399349.
Decree No. 2002-225. 2002. Accessed January 14, 2024.
https://www.legifrance.gouv.fr/jorf/id/JORFTEXT000000780099.
Decree No. 2004-470. 2004. “Décret du 25 mai 2004 modifiant le code de procédure pénale (deuxième partie: Décrets en Conseil d’État) et relatif au fichier national automatisé des empreintes génétiques” [Decree of May 25, 2004, modifying the Code of Criminal Procedure (Part II: Decrees of the State Council) and relating to the national forensic DNA database], Decree No. 2004-470. Last Modified June 2, 2004. Accessed January 14, 2024.
https://www.legifrance.gouv.fr/loda/id/JORFTEXT000000438704.
Denis, Jérôme, and David Pontille. 2015. “Material Ordering and the Care of Things.” Science, Technology, & Human Values 40(3): 338–367.
https://doi.org/10.1177/0162243914553129.
⸻. 2018. “The Multiple Walls of Graffiti Removal: Maintenance and Urban Assemblage in Paris.” In Urban Walls: Political and Cultural Meanings of Vertical Structures and Surfaces, edited by Andrea Mubi Brighenti, and Mattias Kärrholm, 215–235. London, England: Routledge.
https://doi.org/10.4324/9780203730225-11.
⸻. 2019. “The Dance of Maintenance and the Dynamics of Urban Assemblages: The Daily (Re)assemblage of Paris Subway Signs.” In Repair Work Ethnographies: Revisiting Breakdown, Relocating Materiality, edited by Ignaz Strebel, Alain Bovet, and Philippe Sormani, 161–185. London, England: Palgrave Macmillan.
⸻. 2022. Le soin des choses. Politiques de la maintenance [The care of things: Politics of maintenance]. Terrains Philosophiques. Paris: La Découverte.
Domínguez Rubio, Fernando. 2014. “Preserving the Unpreservable: Docile and Unruly Objects at MoMA.” Theory and Society 43: 617–645.
https://doi.org/10.1007/s11186-014-9233-4.
⸻. 2016. “On the Discrepancy between Objects and Things. An Ecological Approach.” Journal of Material Culture 21(1): 59–86.
https://doi.org/10.1177/1359183515624128.
⸻. 2021. “Storage as a Form of Violence.” In Necrography: Death-Writing in the Colonial Museum, Conversation Piece coordinated by Dan Hicks, British Art Studies 19.
https://doi.org/10.17658/issn.2058-5462/issue-19/conversation/p34.
Edensor, Tim. 2011. “Entangled Agencies, Material Networks and Repair in a Building Assemblage: The Mutable Stone of St Ann’s Church, Manchester.” Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers 36: 238–252.
https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1475-5661.2010.00421.x.
Faulkner, Alex, Bettina Lange, and Christopher Lawless. 2012. “Introduction: Material Worlds: Intersections of Law, Science, Technology, and Society.” Journal of Law and Society 39(1): 1–19.
https://www.jstor.org/stable/41350295.
Graham, Stephen, and Nigel Thrift. 2007. “Out of Order: Understanding Repair and Maintenance.” Theory Culture & Society 24(3): 1–25.
https://doi.org/10.1177/0263276407075954.
Grimaldi, Michel, and Bernard Reynis. 2003. “L’acte authentique électronique” [The electronic notarial act]. Répertoire Defrénois 17, 1023.
https://www.labase-lextenso.fr/defrenois/AD2003DEF1023N1.
Henke, Christopher R., and Benjamin Sims. 2020. Repairing Infrastructures: The Maintenance of Materiality and Power. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
https://doi.org/10.7551/mitpress/11771.001.0001.
Houston, Lara, and Steven J. Jackson. 2017. “Caring for the “Next Billion” Mobile Handsets: Opening Proprietary Closures and the Work of Repair.” Information Technologies & International Development 13: 200–214.
https://doi.org/10.1145/2909609.2909658.
Hummel, Cornelia, and David Desaleux. 2018. Mustang: La mécanique de la passion [Mustang: The mechanics of passion]. Lyon: Éditions Libel.
Institut de Recherche Criminelle de la Gendarmerie Nationale-Service Central de Renseignement Criminel de la Gendarmerie Nationale (IRCGN-SCRCGN). [2017] 2023. “Le Service Central de Préservation des Prélèvements Biologiques: De la gestion de scellés biologiques à la résolution d’enquête” [The central service for the preservation of biological samples: From the management of biological seals to the resolution of investigations]. Published June 14, 2017. Last modified November 9, 2023. Accessed March 2, 2023.
Jackson, Steven J. 2014. “Rethinking Repair.” In Media Technologies: Essays in Communication, Materiality, and Society, edited by Tarleton Gillespie, Pablo J. Boczkowski, and Kirsten A. Foot, 221–260. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Jasanoff, Sheila, and Sang-Hyun Kim, eds. 2015. Dreamscapes of Modernity: Sociotechnical Imaginaries and the Fabrication of Power. Chicago and London: The University of Chicago Press.
Jones, Siân, and Thomas Yarrow. 2013. “Crafting Authenticity: An Ethnography of Conservation Practice.” Journal of Material Culture 18(1): 3–26.
https://doi.org/10.1177/1359183512474383.
Kang, Hyo Yoon, and Sara Kendall. 2019. “Contents, Introduction & Contributors.” In “Legal Materiality,” edited by Hyo Yoon Kang and Sara Kendall, special issue, Law Text Culture 23: 1–15. Accessed January 14, 2024.
https://ro.uow.edu.au/ltc/vol23/iss1/1.
Kruse, Corinna. 2016. The Social Life of Forensic Evidence. Berkley, CA: University of California Press.
La Provence. 2021. “Scellés détruits: l’État assigné pour ‘faute lourde’ dans une enquête sur la mort d’une femme” [Destroyed seals: State sued for ‘gross negligence’ in investigation into a woman’s death]. La Provence, April 14, 2021. Accessed January 14, 2024.
Latour, Bruno. 2005. La fabrique du droit: Une ethnographie du Conseil d’État [The making of law: An ethnography of the Conseil d’État]. Paris: La Découverte.
Lezaun, Javier. 2012. “The Pragmatic Sanction of Materials: Notes for an Ethnography of Legal Substances.” Journal of Law and Society 39(1): 20–38.
https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-6478.2012.00568.x.
McGowan, Katharine, and Frances Westley. 2015. “At the Root of Change: The History of Social Innovation.” In New Frontiers in Social Innovation Research, edited by Alex Nicholls, Julie Simon, and Madeleine Gabriel, 52–68. London, England: Palgrave Macmillan.
https://doi.org/10.1057/9781137506801_3.
Pontille, David. 2009. “Écriture et action juridique: Portrait de l’huissier de justice en réparateur” [Writing and legal action: Portrait of the bailiff as a repairer]. Semen: Revue de Sémio-Linguistique des Textes et Discours 28: 15–31.
https://doi.org/10.4000/semen.8688.
Rabeharisoa, Vololona, and Florence Paterson. 2023. “Du sang et des larmes: force et fragilité des scellés biologiques dans la chaîne criminalistique” [Blood and tears: Strength and fragility of sealed biological samples in the forensic chain]. In “Fragilités matérielles” [Material fragilities], special issue edited by David Pontille and Jérôme Denis, Revue d’Anthropologie des Connaissances 17(4).
https://doi.org/10.4000/rac.30829.
Renard, Bertrand. 2008. “Ce que l’ADN fait faire à la justice: Sociologie des traductions dans l’identification par analyse génétique en justice pénale” [What DNA makes justice do: Sociology of translations in DNA identification in criminal justice]. PhD dissertation, Université Catholique de Louvain. Accessed January 14, 2024.
https://dial.uclouvain.be/pr/boreal/object/boreal:158063.
Roparz, Mikaël. 2011. “Le sort des pièces à conviction bientôt scellé.” [The fate of the exhibits is soon to be sealed]. Franceinfo, [Radio France], November 1, 2011. Accessed January 14, 2024.
https://www.francetvinfo.fr/faits-divers/le-sort-des-pieces-a-conviction-bientot-scelle_1662225.html.
Silbey, Susan S., and Ayn Cavicchi. 2005. “The Common Place of Law: Transforming Matters of Concern into the Objects of Everyday Life.” In Making Things Public: Atmospheres of Democracy, edited by Bruno Latour and Peter Wiebel, 556–565. ZKM, Center for Art and Media Karlsruhe. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Strebel, Ignaz, Alain Bovet, and Philippe Sormani, eds. 2019. Repair Work Ethnographies: Revisiting Breakdown, Relocating Materiality. Singapore: Springer Verlag.
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-13-2110-8.
Yurchak, Alexei. 2015. “Bodies of Lenin: The Hidden Science of Communist Sovereignty.” Representations 129(1): 116–157.
