The Politics of Scheduling: Vaccination as Infrastructure, Spectacle, and Market in West Africa, 1960s–1980s

  • Noemi Tousignant

Abstract

Vaccination schedules negotiate the timing of interactions among bodies, vaccines, and pathogens. Yet they do more: they orchestrate the movement of vaccines through factories, business plans, injecting devices, fridges, vehicles, healthcare labour, kinship relations, policy models, government budgets, and so on. This article approaches vaccine schedules as standards that synchronise the varying entities – and interests animating these – that make up vaccination infrastructures broadly defined. What unfolds is an examination of the politics of schedule-setting and implementation, set-out in three debates concerning vaccination in West Africa during a time of fitful, contested expansion in both the delivery of immunizing technologies and the development of basic healthcare infrastructure. The first debate concerns rhythms of vaccination during the US-led and funded West African Smallpox Eradication and Measles Control Program (SEMCP) in the latter 1960s, revealing tensions among this programme’s technopolitical priorities. Two later debates, about the optimal age for measles vaccination, and the minimum total doses/visits required for full immunization, reflect broader contests, from the late 1970s to the late 1980s, over the ultimate goals of the ‘Expanded Programme on Immunization’ (EPI). These three debates provide insight into how multiple actors vied for control over how routine childhood vaccination was to be enacted and imagined in West Africa.

References

Aaby, Peter, Cesário Martins, May-Lill Garly, Amabelia Rodrigues, et al. 2012. “The Optimal Age of Measles Immunisation in Low-income Countries: A Secondary Analysis of the Assumptions Underlying the Current Policy.” BMJ Open 2(4):1–15.

https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2011-000761.

Aaby, Peter, Badara Samb, François Simondon, Awa M. C. Seck, et al. 1995. “Non-specific Beneficial Effect of Measles Immunisation: Analysis of Mortality Studies from Developing Countries.” British Medical Journal 311(7003): 481–485.

https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.311.7003.481.

Bado, Jean-Paul. 1996. Médecine coloniale et grandes endémies en Afrique [Colonial Medicine and Major Endemic Diseases in Africa]. Paris: Karthala.

Beaudevin, Claire, Jean-Paul Gaudillière, Christoph Gradmann, Anne M. Lovell, et al. 2020. “Global Health and the New World Order: Introduction.” In Global Health and the New World Order, edited by Jean-Paul Gaudillière, Claire Beaudevin, Christoph Gradmann, Anne Lovell, and Laurent Pordié. Manchester: Manchester University Press.

https://shs.hal.science/halshs-02976222.

Blume, Stuart S. 2005. “Lock in, the State and Vaccine Development: Lessons from the History of the Polio Vaccines.” Research Policy 34(2): 159–173.

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.respol.2004.12.001.

⸻. 2017. Immunization: How Vaccines Became Controversial. London: Reaktion Books.

Brazelton, Mary A. 2019. Mass Vaccination: Citizens’ Bodies and State Power in Modern China. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.

https://doi.org/10.7591/9781501739996.

Brown, Theodore M., Marcos Cueto, and Elizabeth Fee. 2006. “The World Health Organization and the transition from “international” to “global” public health.” American Journal of Public Health 96(1): 62-72.

https://doi.org/10.2105/ajph.2004.050831.

Clements, C. John, Julie B. Milstien, Mark Grabowsky, J. Gibson, et al. 1988‎. “Research into Alternative Measles Vaccines in the 1990’s.” World Health Organization. Accessed October 7, 2021.

https://apps.who.int/iris/handle/10665/62234.

Conis, Elena. 2015. Vaccine Nation: America’s Changing Relationship with Immunization. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

https://doi.org/10.7208/chicago/9780226923772.001.0001.

Cueto, Marcos, Theodore M. Brown, and Elizabeth Fee. 2019. The World Health Organization: A History. Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press.

https://doi.org/10.1017/9781108692878.

Feldman‐Savelsberg, Pamela, Flavien T. Ndonko, and Bergis Schmidt‐Ehry. 2000. “Sterilizing Vaccines or the Politics of the Womb: Retrospective Study of a Rumor in Cameroon.” Medical Anthropology Quarterly 14(2): 159–179.

https://doi.org/10.1525/maq.2000.14.2.159.

Foege, William H. 2018. The Task Force for Child Survival: Secrets of Successful Coalitions. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.

https://doi.org/10.56021/9781421425603.

Garenne, Michel. 2018. “Témoignage d’une aventure scientifique à Niakhar (1981–1991)” [Firsthand Account of a Scientific Adventure in Niakhar (1981–1991)]. In Niakhar mémoires et perspectives: Recherches pluridisciplinaires sur le changement en Afrique [Niakhar, Memories and Perspectives: Multidisciplinary Research on Change in Africa], edited by Valérie Delaunay, Alice Desclaux, and Cheikh Sokhna, 43–66. Dakar and Marseille: L’Harmattan-Sénégal; IRD.

https://doi.org/10.4000/books.irdeditions.31367.

Gaudilliere, Jean-Paul, and Camille Gasnier. 2020. “From Washington DC to Washington State: The Global Burden of Diseases Data Basis and the Political Economy of Global Health.” In Data Journeys in the Sciences, edited by Sabina Leonelli and Niccolò Tempini, 351–369. Springer Open.

http://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-37177-7.

Gosselin, Etienne. 2012. “Constructing International Health: The Communicable Disease Center, Field Epidemiologists and the Politics of Foreign Assistance (1948–1972).” Doctoral Thesis, McGill University.

https://escholarship.mcgill.ca/concern/theses/4t64gs32d.

Henderson, Ralph, and Victoria Harden. 2006. “Henderson, Ralph ‘Rafe’.” Harden interviewing Henderson. Global Health Chronicles, July 7, 2006. Accessed March 26, 2021.

https://globalhealthchronicles.org/items/show/3525.

Henderson, David Alexander. 2024. Target Zero: Smallpox Eradication Archive.

https://zero-pox.info/.

Hendrickse, Ralph G. 1975. “Problems of Futures Measles Vaccination in Developing Countries.” Transactions of the Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 69(1): 31-34.

https://doi.org/10.1016/0035-9203(75)90007-3.

Heymann, David L., Kevin R. Murphy, Georges K. Mayben, Bernard Guyer, et al. 1983. “Measles Control in Yaounde: Justification of a One Dose, Nine-month Minimum Age Vaccination Policy in Tropical Africa.” The Lancet 322(8365): 1470–1472.

https://doi.org/10.1016/s0140-6736(83)90813-9.

Jafflin, Kristen L. G. 2013. “The Power of Immunization: The WHO and Global Immunization Programs from 1974 to the Present.” Doctoral Thesis, University of California Berkeley.

https://escholarship.org/content/qt3p82180k/qt3p82180k.pdf?t=ny5vfa.

Jacobs, Charlotte DeCroes. 2015. Jonas Salk: A Life. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Jeannès, Marie-Bérangère. 1996. “La rougeole en Afrique de l’Ouest francophone 1930–1970” [Measles in Francophone West Africa 1930-1970]. Doctoral Thesis, University Paris 7.

Labusquière, René. 1967. “Mass Rubeola Immunization in Africa.” Conference paper presented at the First International Conference on Vaccines against Viral and Rickettsial Diseases of Man, Pan American Health Organization and the World Health Organization (WHO), November 7–11, Washington, DC Scientific Publication 147: 312–317. Accessed September 20, 2024.

https://iris.paho.org/bitstream/handle/10665.2/48039/40205.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y.

Lachenal, Guillaume. 2014. Le médicament qui devait sauver l’Afrique: Un scandale pharmaceutique aux colonies [The Drug that Was Meant to Save Africa: A Pharmaceutical Scandal in the Colonies]. Paris: La Découverte.

https://doi.org/10.3917/dec.lache.2014.01.

Manela, Erez. 2010. “A Pox on Your Narrative: Writing Disease Control into Cold War History.” Diplomatic History 34(2): 299–323.

https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-7709.2009.00850.x.

Martin, Jacques-François. 1984. “Consequences of the Introduction of the New Inactivated Poliovirus Vaccine into the Expanded Programme on Immunization.” Reviews of Infectious Diseases 6(S2): S480–2.

https://doi.org/10.1093/clinids/6.Supplement_2.S480.

Masquelier, Adeline M. 2001. “Behind the Dispensary’s Prosperous Façade: Imagining the State in Rural Niger.” Public Culture 13(2): 267–92.

https://doi.org/10.1215/08992363-13-2-267.

Millar, J. Donald. 1970. “Introduction – Principles and Goals of Maintenance Programmes.” In The SEP Report: Seminar on Smallpox Eradication and Measles Control in Western and Central Africa: Proceedings of a Meeting Held in Lagos, Nigeria, May 13–20, 1969, Part 2, 138-139. Accessed March 26, 2021.

http://www.zero-pox.info/cdc/cdc_rpt70_iv2.pdf.

Millward, Gareth. 2019. Vaccinating Britain: Mass Vaccination and the Public Since the Second World War. Manchester: Manchester University Press.

https://doi.org/10.7765/9781526126764.

Nau, Jean-Yves, and Claire Trean. 2000. “Lapeyssonnie, l’éveilleur d’Afrique” [Lapeyssonnie, the Awakener of Africa], Le Monde, January 16, 2000. Accessed October 17, 2021.

https://www.lemonde.fr/archives/article/2000/01/16/lapeyssonnie-l-eveilleur-d-afrique_3591465_1819218.html.

Ogden, Horace G. 1987. CDC and the Smallpox Crusade. US Department of Health and Human Services. Washington DC: Government Printing Office. Accessed October 7, 2021.

https://www.globalhealthchronicles.org/files/original/8c1f35f97d76019c34ed82a05424e14d.pdf.

Packard, Randall M. 2016. A History of Global Health: Interventions into the Lives of Other Peoples. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.

https://doi.org/10.56021/9781421420325.

Pearson, Jessica Lynne. 2018. The Colonial Politics of Global Health: France and the United Nations in Postwar Africa. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.

https://doi.org/10.4159/9780674989283.

Reinhardt, Bob H. 2015. The End of a Global Pox: America and the Eradication of Smallpox in the Cold War Era. Chapel Hill: UNC Press Books.

https://doi.org/10.5149/northcarolina/9781469624099.001.0001.

Runcie, Sarah Cook. 2017. Mobile Health Teams, Decolonization, and the Eradication Era in Cameroon, 1945–1970. Doctoral Thesis, Columbia University.

https://doi.org/10.7916/D8HD872N.

Smith, E. Ademola, S. O. Daniels, and Stanley O. Foster. 1969. “Measles in Lagos, Nigeria.” In The SEP Report: Seminar on Smallpox Eradication and Measles Control in Western and Central Africa: Proceedings of a Meeting Held in Lagos, Nigeria, May 13–20, 1969, Part 2, 19-26. Centers for Disease Control / US Department of Health and Welfare. Volume 4, Number 2, January 30, 1970. Accessed 26, March 2021.

http://www.zero-pox.info/cdc/cdc_rpt70_iv2.pdf.

Thomas, Gaëtan. 2016. “La France et l’Afrique, en parallèle: Les essais vaccinaux de la station pilote du Centre international de l’enfance dans les années 1970” [France and Africa, in Parallel: Vaccine Trials at the Pilot Station of the International Centre for Childhood in the 1970s]. In Le Centre International de l’enfance (1949–1997): Des archives à l’histoire [The International Centre for Childhood (1949–1997): From the Archives to History], edited by Yves Denéchère and Patrice Marcilloux, 155–70. Rennes: Presses Universitaires de Rennes.

https://doi.org/10.4000/books.pur.45189.

⸻. 2020. “Keeping Vaccination Simple: Building French Immunization Schedules, 1959–1999.” Bulletin of the History of Medicine 94(3): 423–458.

https://doi.org/10.1353/bhm.2020.0071.

Tousignant, Noémi. 2012. “Trypanosomes, Toxicity and Resistance: The Politics of Mass Therapy in French Colonial Africa.” Social History of Medicine 25(3): 625–643.

https://doi.org/10.1093/shm/hks005.

Vargha, Dóra. 2018. Polio Across the Iron Curtain: Hungary’s Cold War with an Epidemic. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

https://doi.org/10.1017/9781108355421.

Velmet, Aro. 2020. Pasteur’s Empire: Bacteriology and Politics in France, Its Colonies, and the World. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

https://doi.org/10.1093/oso/9780190072827.001.0001.

Walsh, Julia A. 1983. “Selective Primary Health Care: Strategies for Control of Disease in the Developing World. IV. Measles.” Reviews of Infectious Diseases 5(2): 330–340.

https://doi.org/10.1093/clinids/5.2.330.

Whittle, Hilton C., M. G. M. Rowland, G. F. Mann, and W. H. Lamb, et al. 1984. “Immunisation of 4–6 Month Old Gambian Infants with Edmonston-Zagreb Measles Vaccine.” The Lancet 324(8407): 834–837.

https://doi.org/10.1016/s0140-6736(84)90873-0.

World Health Organization (WHO). 1975‎. “First WHO Seminar on Expansion of the Use of Immunization in Developing Countries, Kumasi, Ghana, 12–19 November 1974.” WHO.

https://apps.who.int/iris/handle/10665/36980.

World Health Organization (WHO) and Expanded Programme on Immunization (EPI). 1988.” Report of the Expanded Programme on Immunization, Global Advisory Group Meeting, 9-13 November 1987, Washington, D.C.” World Health Organization.

https://iris.who.int/handle/10665/62526.

World Health Organization (WHO), Expanded Programme on Immunization (EPI). ‎1990‎. “Report of the Expanded Programme on Immunization, Global Advisory Group Meeting, 16–20 October 1989.” Global Advisory Group 12th Meeting, Tokyo, Japan. Accessed September 20, 2024.

https://apps.who.int/iris/handle/10665/61359.

World Health Organization (WHO), Expanded Programme on Immunization (EPI), and United Nations Children’s Fund (‎UNICEF)‎. ‎1990. “Measles Control in the 1990s: Introduction of High Titre Measles Vaccines / A Joint WHO/UNICEF Statement.” World Health Organization. Accessed September 20, 2024.

https://apps.who.int/iris/handle/10665/60413.

Archival References

Archives of the University of Angers Library (AUAL). 1976. “Compte-rendu de la réunion du 18 juin 1976 [Minutes of the Meeting of June 18, 1976],” 1 CIDEF 115, AUAL, Angers, France.

⸻. 1977. “Compte rendu de la réunion sur le vaccin antipolio inactive concentré, tenue le 8 juin 1977 à Bilthoven” [Minutes of the Meeting on the Concentrated Inactivated Polio Vaccine, Held on June 8, 1977, in Bilthoven], 1 CIDEF115, AUAL.

⸻. 1978. “UIPMP – APMP/comité consultatif technique, 5 juillet 1978 [UIPMP-APMP/Technical Consultation Committee, July 5, 1978], ” 1 CIDEF115, AUAL.

⸻. 1984. “Procès-verbal du Conseil d’Administration de l’APMP, 19 janvier 1984” [Minutes of the APMP Board of Directors, January 19, 1984], 1 CIDEF 78, AUAL.

Brenzel, Logan, Pierre Claquin, Iain McLellan, and Sally Stansfeld. 1987. “Rapid Assessment of Senegal’s Assessment Phase, prepared for UNICEF, November 1987,” in File I8-370-2SEN Jacket 2, WHO Archives.

Buck, Alfred A., Robert Dyar, Ralph Paffenbarger, and Jerome S. Peterson. 1971. “Consultants’ Report. Evaluation: Smallpox Eradication and Measles Control Program.” In USAID Document PD-AAA-548-A1. May 19, 1971, accessed October 7, 2021.

https://pdf.usaid.gov/pdf_docs/PDAAA548A1.pdf.

Caudrelier, Pierre. n.d. “Le programme élargi simplifié de vaccination de la zone pilote de Kolda (Sénégal): Aspects généraux et financiers, APMP” [The Simplified Expanded Vaccination Program for the Pilot Zone of Kolda (Senegal): General and Financial Aspects, APMP], in File I8-370-2SEN, Jacket 1, WHO Archives, Geneva.

Emmet, William L. R., Amadou D. Niane, and Association for the Promotion of Preventive Medicine (APMP). 1984. “ Évaluation de la proposition de programme élargi de vaccination présentée par la République du Sénégal à la conférence de Bellagio (Italie) du 12–16 mars 1984” [Evaluation of the Proprosal for an Expanded Programme on Immunization Presented by the Republic of Senegal to the Bellagio (Italy) Conference, March 12–16, 1984, Dakar, July 18, 1984, in File I8-370-2SEN, Jacket 1, WHO Archives.

Enders, John F., and Joseph Stokes. c.1964. Mission, Measles: The Story of a Vaccine (United States Public Health Service). Potomac Films and Merck Sharp & Dohme, 20 min.

http://resource.nlm.nih.gov/8901910A.

Fillastre, Collette. 1983. Letter of Collette Fillastre (CIE) to Nizar Ajjan (Institut Mérieux), July 28, 1983, in 1 CIDEF 78, Archives of the University of Angers Library (AUAL).

Gelfand, Henry. 1966. “Memorandum,” in “Measles Control & Smallpox Eradication Program, Technical Assistance Paper, July 1966,” USAID Document PD-AAB-609-B1, accessed October 7, 2021.

http://pdf.usaid.gov/pdf_docs/PDAAB609B1.pdf.

Global Health Chronicles. 2024. Global Health Chronicles. Public Health Archives. Website. Accessed November 13, 2024.

https://globalhealthchronicles.org/.

Hayden, Gregory F. 1987. Letter of Gregory F. Hayden to Stanley Foster, November 30, 1987, File I8-446-6, Jacket 3, EPI Diseases Vaccines-Veasles, 1986–87, WHO Archives, Geneva.

Henderson, Ralph. 1977. “Memorandum from Program Manager EPI: Recommended Age for Measles Vaccination, 7 July 1977,” File I8-446-6 Jacket 1, EPI Diseases vaccine – Measles, 1976–84, WHO Archives, Geneva.

⸻. 1984. Letter of Ralph Henderson to William R. Taylor, January 13, 1984, File I8-446-6, Jacket 1, EPI Diseases vaccine – Measles, 1976–84, WHO Archives, Geneva.

⸻. 1985. Letter of Ralph Henderson to David Morley, June 20, 1985, File I8-446-6, Jacket 2, EPI Diseases vaccines- measles, 1985–86, WHO Archives, Geneva.

⸻. 1987. Letter of Ralph Henderson to George Curlin, December 3, 1987, File I8-446-6, Jacket 3, EPI Diseases vaccines-measles, 198687, WHO Archives, Geneva.

Lapointe, Marc. 1987. Letter of Marc Lapointe to Rafe Henderson, April 10, 1987, in File I8-370-2SEN, Jacket 2, WHO Archives, Geneva.

McLellan, Iain. c.1987. “‘Background - History of Social Mobilisation in Senegal,’ Productions Nord-Sud,” Unpublished. File I8-370-2SEN, Jacket 2, WHO Archives, Geneva.

Ministry of Public Health and World Health Organization (WHO), with the Association for the Promotion of Preventive Medicine (APMP). 1984. “Évaluation nationale du PEV au Sénégal, 23–29 Juillet, 1984” [National Evaluation of EPI in Senegal, July 23–29, 1984], in File I8-370-2SEN, Jacket 1, WHO Archives, Geneva.

North, W. Haven. 1970. “Action Memorandum for the Assistant Administrator, from W. Haven North to David Shear, 5 January 1970” in PD-AAB-609-B1.

Schlumberger, Dr. n.d. “Zone Pilote de Kolda – Evaluation épidémiologique, méthodes, APMP” [Kolda Pilot Zone – Epidemiological Evaluation, Methods, APMP], in 1 CIDEF 78, AUAL.

Sylla, Mady Oury. c.1984. “Présentation du plan d’action du PEV/Bellagio, République du Sénégal” [Presentation of the EPI/Bellagio Action Plan, Republic of Senegal], in File I8-370-2SEN, Jacket 1, WHO Archives, Geneva.

Stoeckel, Philippe. 1982. Letter of Philippe Stoeckel to Robert Mande, April 7, 1982, CIDEF-78, Archives of the University of Angers Library (AUAL).

United States Agency for International Development (USAID). 2024. Development Experience Clearinghouse. Website. Accessed November 13, 2024.

https://www.usaid.gov/.

⸻. 1966. “Project for Smallpox Eradication and Measles Control in 19 Countries of West Africa,” in Measles Control & Smallpox Eradication Program, Technical Assistance Paper. Staff Memorandum. July 1966. USAID Document PD-AAB-609-B1, accessed October 7, 2021.

http://pdf.usaid.gov/pdf_docs/PDAAB609B1.pdf.

⸻. 1970. “Measles Control and Smallpox Eradication Program Dated January 5, 1970,” in USAID document PD-AAB-609-B1, 259, accessed October 7, 2021.

https://dec.usaid.gov/dec/GetDoc.axd?ctID=ODVhZjk4NWQtM2YyMi00YjRmLTkxNjktZTcxMjM2NDBmY2Uy&rID=MTk0NjQ=&pID=NTYw&attchmnt=True&uSesDM=False&rIdx=MTgxNjU=&rCFU=.

⸻. 1983. “Minutes: Consultative Group to Protect the World’s Children, The Harvard Club of New York, October 24, 1983,” in USAID document PN–ABP–828, Bellagio Conference, March 12–16, 1984, 1–5. Accessed September 19, 2024.

https://dec.usaid.gov/dec/GetDoc.axd?ctID=ODVhZjk4NWQtM2YyMi00YjRmLTkxNjktZTcxMjM2NDBmY2Uy&pID=NTYw&attchmnt=VHJ1ZQ==&rID=Njk1MjI=.

World Health Organization (WHO) Archives. 1985a. “Workshop on the Use of Measles Vaccine in Children under 9 Months of Age, CDC, 21-22 November 1985,” File I8-446-6, Jacket 2, EPI Diseases vaccines- measles, 1985–86, WHO Archives, Geneva.

⸻. 1985b. “EPI-SENEGAL, 1985” in File I8-370-2SEN, Jacket 2, WHO Archives. Unpublished report.

⸻. c.1986. “Rapport sur le programme élargi de vaccination [Report on the Expanded Programme on Immunisation,” in File I8-370-2SEN, Jacket 2, WHO Archives, Geneva.

⸻. 2024a. Measles. Fact Sheet. Modified July 12, 2024, accessed November 12, 2024.

https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/measles.

⸻. 2024b. Institutional Repository for Information Sharing. Website. Accessed November 13, 2024.

https://iris.who.int/.

Published
01 Dec 2024
Section
Thematic Collection: Standards & their Containers